Saft on Wealth: Sitting out Europe’s rodeo
By James SaftOct 13 (Reuters) - Here is something every wealth manager
thinking about betting big on Europe should consider:Ask yourself, do you have special insight into euro zone
politics, or do you just feel lucky?Because in the end, this thing is not going to be about
economics, or even about the art of the possible, it will be
about will, envy, aspiration and caprice.If you as a manager think you can add value by guessing at
imponderables, by figuring out exactly what the euro project is
worth to its countries, then by all means, advise your clients
to take a big bet.For us mortals, the best course by far is a slight
underweight, with care taken not to lose money in obvious risky
bets like financials and the bonds of struggling euro zone
nations.The irony is that this means you are taking a bit of a pass
on the biggest question in financial markets today. If Europe
is somehow able to reconcile itself to a mutually agreeable
bail out of its weak nations and a credible recapitalization of
its banks, well then shares will soar.We’ve seen hints of this every time authorities there
announce a new resolution, no matter how vague, to “fix” the
problems.Or Europe can end very badly in any number of ways: a
fracture of the weak from the strong, an inability to come to
political terms over who pays or simply a crisis brought on by
a market panic that happens too quickly for policy-makers to
cope.Since the stakes are so high it is very tempting to take a
strong position. We can be tempted by very low valuations and
the chance of big gains or we can panic in the face of very
high uncertainty and decide to just get out. It’s also hard not
to want to appear decisive to others, especially if they are
paying you for advice.Europe’s difficulties, though, are tremendously complex and
are essentially about political risk, which is many orders of
magnitude more difficult to measure and play then the other
sorts of calculations investors usually make.One of the secrets of investing is the importance of
humility and a proper respect for uncertainty. It’s a good bet
this is a lesson a lot of people are soon going to learn, yet
again.DON’T JUST DO SOMETHING, STAND THEREThat’s not to say I don’t think I have a line on how things
in the euro zone are going to work out, or at least the very
real limitations to the spectrum of outcomes.The facts on the ground are not encouraging. For the euro
to survive as is, Europe needs to give new powers to the ECB
and its nations need to cede much individual control over
fiscal policy to the whole. Doing that democratically in short
order is going to be difficult.As well, Europe’s banks need massive amounts of new
capital, the impact of which is going to keep a very low
ceiling on economic growth for several years. Even if you
believe all of that, acting as if it were 100 percent true is
extremely risky.The other issue, to be frank, is pain attribution. European
assets will, obviously, get hit hardest if Europe falls apart
or if it sticks together in a way that is negative for
investors. U.S. assets will get hit too.The reaction of investors to those two types of losses,
however, we be entirely different. If you have a client long
Europe and Europe falls apart, her reaction will likely be “Why
on earth did you have me messing around over there?”But if the US market gets hit by euro fallout, as well they
will, the reaction will be more sanguine. Investors will feel
more the way they do when struck by a natural disaster. Bad
luck, but what are you going to do?This is a correct, if instinctual, read by wealthy
investors. While diversification is good, and getting out of
Europe entirely would be foolish, taking on extra risk in a
foreign currency must be approached cautiously. If you are
going to live in the U.S., as domestic clients do and will, you
are pretty much stuck with having most of your exposure
concentrated at home, for better or worse.The idea that globalization means that investors can float
free of their home markets is a fantasy, as most Greeks will
tell you.It is an easy call for U.S. investors to sit out Europe’s
rodeo because they can’t manage the political risks.Unfortunately, the same underlying causes of Europe’s
political difficulties - too much debt and slow growth - are
also causing political risk to become a big feature in U.S.
investing. Think about the U.S. debt downgrade and near
government shutdown.Investors are ultimately going to have to learn how to
cope.
60 notes
button

